Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ilana Masad's avatar

I really, really, REALLY appreciated this piece, James (and P.E.!). I think this is one of the most frustrating things to me about certain leftist discourse - that it ends up being as unnuanced and empty as some of the terrible thinking on the right. We need to get better at being able to hold various truths in our minds at the same time - which is harder, often, than finding one truth that seems to cover all the bases. Anyway, as a depressed and anxious and traumatized etc. etc. person, I very much appreciate you writing about the issues with looking at mental illness through a structural lens and nothing else.

Expand full comment
Wendi Gordon's avatar

This is one of the best articles on mental health I’ve ever read! After living with depression and anxiety for most of my life, I’ve only recently come to understand how society’s screwed up values - especially capitalism’s prioritization of profits over people and definition of success purely in terms of wealth and power - contribute to my mental health issues.

At the same time, I also know how much better I feel when I do things like journal each morning, take nature walks, pay attention to my emotional pain instead of trying to distract myself from feeling it, and challenge my negative thoughts.

Doing those things gives me the courage and strength to do what I can to address the larger societal problems.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts